Recently, everybody has been paying attention to the low ranking of
Canada's health system by the World Health Organization (WHO)(1).
Canada has been ranked 30th while France and Italy have been ranked
respectively 1st and 2nd. This abysmal ranking of the Canadian
health system has received the attention of our policy makers and
health professionals. Dr. Hugh Scully, president of the Canadian
Medical Association, has stated "It's a wake up, folks,... we have
to pay close attention to this or we're going to be in trouble."
In Ottawa, a spokesman for Health Canada said the federal
government welcomed the WHO analysis as exactly the kind of "report
card" that Allan Rock, the federal Health Minister, has been
advocating for years(2). Health Minister Pat Atkinson said that the
WHO survey may also prove the point that quality health care is not
just about more money(3).
Again, I am smiling with sadness realizing again and again about
the lack of common sense of our leadership. The first responsibility
is to clean up our home, yet we delegate this responsibility to
outside agencies, that is we have to look at our neighbours' homes
to see if our home is clean enough! This demented mentality of our
leadership reminds me of the precarious situation of our provincial
universities and to the final realization that the University of
Saskatchewan is lagging behind just because it was ranked 14 out of
15 Canadian universities by a survey conducted by Macleans's
magazine(4).
Again, this demented mentality has been the major cause of our
health care problem, here in Saskatchewan, when for example the
provincial health districts are ranked by Saskatchewan Health in
accordance to their utilization of their resources(5), when this
ranking is the motivating factor for stimulating competition and
streamline health care services across the province, when this
ranking occurs in the absence of sound accounting practices and
market competition, and when this ranking occurs at the time the
health districts break the law by posting operating deficits!
We have been talking for sometime about the value of statistics,
and how this government is delegating its responsibilities to
researchers. In Canada, we have been playing the black and white
research game between public and health care(6)(7), now, in
Saskatchewan, we have Mr. Ken Fyke's year long and two million
dollar review of medicare(8). Statistics don't tell us all the
stories of our problems and challenges. In the absence of our own
responsibility, there will never be a statistical study which is
going to provide a fix to our health care crisis. Our health care
crisis is not one man's problem, and it is not going to be solved by
giving two million dollars to fatten the expenditures of Mr. Ken
Fyke. Dr. David Cassidy's studies on no-fault insurance cost over a
million dollars and it has proven that he is a cheater, that our
University of Saskatchewan is an accomplice cheater, that the
Saskatchewan Government Insurance (SGI) is a cheater, that our
government is a cheater(9)!
I tell you what some people have been saying about WHO's ranking
of the health systems(10), that France and Italy have the best
health systems for the simple reasons that their populations have
better eating habits(11) and they drink the best wines in the
world(12)! I am sure that this remark makes you laugh, and certainly
you must laugh as you must laugh at all statistics provided to us
without any relevant story(13). We must not be worried about
Canada's report card by WHO. What we must worry is about what is
happening at home. In the last two weeks, we have received the news
that pathologists(14) and pediatricians(15) are leaving the province
in bulks, that the Health department is missing the deadline for
approving the districts' budgets(16), that some health districts are
penalized just for doing a better job than others(17), that hospital
beds are being closed because of staffing shortages(18).
Honourable Roy Romanow and Honourable Pat Atkinson, you don't
have to look at Canada's report card by the WHO to have a wake up
call. You had ten years to wake up and instead you chose to be cozy
and covered up in the bedrooms of the province for all of these
years(19). Now, I kindly tell you that your research games and your
continuing lying are spilling out all over the world and that it is
time for you and your friends to move aside and take some fresh
clean air, for your health care and of course, for our own health
care as well as for the Canadian and Saskatchewan health care.
References & Endnotes
We must break down Premier Roy Romanow's myth that the system is
more worth than individual rights. The law and order mentality of
our justice system for protecting the individual rights of
Saskatchewan people can be summarized by Serge Kujawa's statement
made back in 1991 "It doesn't matter if Milgaard is innocent... The
whole judicial system is at issue-it's worth more than one person."
Serge Kujawa is a former prosecutor and colleague of Premier Roy
Romanow.
General reference: Articles by Mario deSantis published by Ensign
1. Canada's health system ranks 30th, by Marc Kennedy, The
StarPhoenix, June 21, 2000, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan
2. Canada No. 30 on health: study. Behind Cyprus, Morocco: Report
described as 'part science and part prognostication', Mark Kennedy,
Ottawa Citizen, June 21, 2000 http://www.nationalpost.com/printer.asp?f=000621/323527
3. Cash not cure-all for health care, Atkinson says, by Murray
Mandryk, The StarPhoenix, June 22, 2000, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan
4. U of S ranks 14 out of 15: Why not being the best of yourself!
By Mario deSantis, November 12, 1999 http://www.ftlcomm.com/ensign/desantisArticles/desantis82/UofS-Nov12-99.html
5. The need for a management accounting system to address the
current problems of accountability and performance in Saskatchewan
Health Reform, by Mario deSantis, June 1995. A relevant excerpt of
the paper "the utilization rates of resources and the related
ranking of the districts do not provide valuable information to
assist DHBs [District Health Boards] in redirecting their resources"
6. A Partial Diagnosis of Health Care Corruption: The Quality
Circle of the Big Brains Includes Our Renown Health Economists, by
Mario deSantis, March 9, 2000
http://www.ftlcomm.com/ensign/desantisArticles/2000/desantis135/DeclineHealth.html
7. Private sector has a role in health care, Madelaine Drohan,
Globe and Mail, June 21 2000
http://www.globeandmail.com/gam/ROBColumns/20000621/RMADD.html
8. The Commission on Medicare: Another expert, another vision,
and another number, by Mario deSantis, June 14, 2000
http://www.ftlcomm.com/ensign/desantisArticles/2000/desantis181/healthcarecommission.html
9. Refer to the detailed documentation of the No-Fault Insurance
review by The Coalition Against No-Fault, Box 24007, 240 Albert
Steet, Regina, Saskatchewan S4R 8R8, (306)546-4424,
coalition@dlcwest.com
http://www.angelfire.com/nf/coalitionagainstnf/
10. WHO is losing ground to the plague of statistics, Brad
Evenson, National Post, June 21, 2000
http://www.nationalpost.com/printer.asp?f=000621/323580
11. The health of nations, Economist, June 24-30 2000.
Observation by Julian Le Grand of the London School of Economics.
12. This observation that France and Italy have the best health
systems was made by my son Eric as I talked to him about the WHO's
ranking of health systems (Saskatoon: June 25, 2000)
13. The misuse of Statistics as a scientific tool, by Mario
deSantis, January 18, 2000 http://www.ftlcomm.com/ensign/desantisArticles/2000/desantis99/StatsSurvey.html
14. Pathology in critical condition: doctor. Resignations further
burden system, West says, by Jason Warick, The StarPhoenix, June 10,
2000, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan
15. Prognosis grim for pediatrics. Long shifts driving more
specialists out of province, by Jason Warick, The StarPhoenix, June
19, 2000, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan
16. Health dept. misses deadline on district deficit plan, by
Murray Mandryk, The StarPhoenix, June 22, 2000, Saskatoon,
Saskatchewan
17. Prince Albert health district half a million in the red, CBC
Saskatchewan http://sask.cbc.ca/ Web Posted | Jun 22 2000 7:50 PM
EDT
18. Climax health centre closed on weekends, CBC Saskatchewan
http://sask.cbc.ca/ Web Posted | Jun 23 2000 6:47 PM EDT
19. Government Mistrust in Saskatchewan: The Continuous Saga, by
Mario deSantis and reviewed by James deSantis, June 4, 2000 http://www.ftlcomm.com/ensign/desantisArticles/2000/desantis177/Mistrust.html
|