We must be careful about being complacent and rejoice to the news
that Canada is again number one in standard of living(1) after being
ranked 30 with respect to its health care system(2). The most
important consideration in assessing our economic and social
performance doesn't come from the ranking of our status by
Statistics Canada nor from the United Nations; we must look at
ourselves in the mirror and we will find the answer, that is what we
need is to put more value to our common sense and less value to the
ongoing reductionist statistics of economic performance.
Canada's real personal income has decreased by 5% i n the last 10
years, while the United States' real personal income has increased
by 13% (3). Today, the gap between the Canadian and US personal
income is some US$6,000 (CND$9,000) and therefore we must recognize
that this economic under achievement is mainly the result of
regressive and outdated economic policies of our federal and
provincial governments. And our comparative under achievement
doesn't limit to the US, in fact France has been growing three times
faster, Norway six times faster and Ireland eighteen times faster.
Ireland has become the fastest growing economy in Europe and its
social and economic policies are today taken as an example to follow
by any other country. Lower taxes, foreign investments, research and
education have been the main strategic components for the economic
growth of Ireland(4).
In Canada , we have always pursued economic growth by attracting
foreign capital, and therefore in the last budget an effort was put
to improve our higher educational system by announcing the creation
of 2,000 research chairs. In accordance to many politicians and
economists what is left is to pursue the cutting of personal and
corporate taxes. The creation of 2000 research chairs at the expense
of improving the basic education of our youth is a debatable
economic decision, and if we consider Ireland, we must point out
that this country began to pour money into basic education in the
60's and only after that they put money into research and
development.
If we refer to Saskatchewan, the cutting of personal or corporate
taxes will not do, by itself, the trick to spur economic growth,
especially so when one considers the tremendous and futile funding
in research(5) at the expense of providing better education for our
young children and our university graduates(6).
Most of our aboriginal people live in poverty, and their
percentage of the population is expected to rise from the present
14% to 45% by the year 2045 and unless we focus on the needs of
these people we will become a socially bankrupt province. Eric
Cline, Minister of Finance for Saskatchewan, has been trumpeting
economic growth for the last nine years(7), yet our real economic
growth has been decreasing and deteriorating, and our aboriginal
people are continuing to suffer in silence the consequences of these
governmental policies. The highest economic priority of this
province is education, then lower taxes , and certainly not the
phoney research presently carried out by our universities.
References and Endnotes
CANADA'S ECONOMY IN THE NEWSPAPERS, by Brian K. MacLea n,
MacLean's Economic Policy Page http://www.geocities.com/brian79/macecon.html
Articles by Mario deSantis published by Ensign
1. Canada's No. 1, United Nations says, Steven Edwards, National
Post, June 29, 2000
2. The Rubbish of the WHO's Ranking and Saskatchewan Health, by
Mario deSantis, June 25, 2000
3. CANADA'S STANDARD OF LIVING: WHY DO WE LAG BEHIND THE U.S.?
Productivity is only part of the problem, Marc LE9vesque, Ruth
Getter, May 26, 1999, Toronto Dominion Bank http://www.tdbank.ca/tdeconomics/marketanalysis/current/ml0526.htm
4. It takes more than a simple tax cut and the luck of the Irish,
Madelaine Drohan, Globe and Mail, July 4, 2000
5. Research, Reputations and Responsibility, by Timothy Shire,
July 2, 2000
6. Honourable Eric Cline has not balanced the budget yet, he
forgot our school-children, by Mario deSantis, April 2, 2000
7. Budget Address: A Plan forGrowth and Opportunity, Honourable
Eric Cline, Minister of Finance, Government of Saskatchewan, March,
2000 http://www.gov.sk.ca/finance/budget/budget00/2000papers.htm
|