I have a deep respect for the outstanding work of Ralph Nader to
advance the causes to protect consumers at large and democracy.
However, in the complex world we live in we can't make over
simplifications. Nader spoke at the University of Toronto, lashed
out at the corporation domination of society, and mentioned that a
hypothetical US left wing government would have constrained the
power of the big corporations and would have studied a health-care
system modelled on Canada(1). He said that the electoral battle
between President Bush and Al Gore was nothing else but a side show
since the people who make the decisions are the big corporations,
who dominate one department after another, one agency after another.
Nader also stated that the corporations tightened their grip on the
political system by virtue of the surrender of the Democratic Party
and a weakening of the trade unions.
I am a bit annoyed when I hear of a left or right wing government
when our real problems are ones of democracy, of poverty and social
inequality. Certainly we need political parties to advance our
social and economic causes, they bring different leadership,
different social and economic perspectives, but again these
political parties must speak a common language, a social and
economic language everybody can understand. And the common language
is that language which provides our well-being and therefore the
people active participation in our communities' life, having jobs,
having healthy families, having education, pursuing our social and
cultural aspirations.
We don't have to have a fight against the corporation domination,
we must just change our language and pursue our social growth not
because we increase our GDP but because we live healthier lives. Our
social and economic problem is not one of being more or less
capitalistic, or more or less socialistic; we can't change our
social and cultural experiences, but we can all pursue the social
and economic vision to be healthier. Therefore, all of our political
and economic efforts must be measured in terms of how these efforts
will affect our well-being, and not how these efforts will affect
the GDP. And as I already mentioned in a previous article, we have
social economists who are getting away from traditional economic
indexes of performance, and they are putting more emphasis on our
well-being and on how active social programs(2) can increase our
well-being(3). And the corporation and the trade union businesses
would just be a matter of consequence.
Therefore, the current strive of our Canadian bankers, business
leaders and politicians to rally our passion to overcome the US
standard of living in the next 15 years(4) is a futile and senseless
crusade. And as the bankers have been making money at the expense of
people at large(5), so we have Canadian Crusader Charles Baillie,
Chairman & Chief Executive Officer of TD Bank Financial Group,
preaching the bank's gospel that our goal should be to increase our
standard of living so that in 15 years it is not just equal to the
United States, but it is better ... On average, we have to have 1.6
percentage points faster growth than the United States, every year,
for 15 years. If the U.S. economy were to grow on average 3.4 per
cent per year, we would have to grow 5 per cent(6).
And the GDP Canadian saga continues at the expense of democracy
and for the ongoing benefit of the bankers(7), the government, big
corporations and their friends.
References/endnotes
Relevant political and economics articles http://www.ftlcomm.com/ensign
1. Nader blasts corporate domination, MARTIN MITTELSTAEDT, The
Globe and Mail, March 2, 2001 http://www.theglobeandmail.com/gam/National/20010302/UNADEM.html
2. Growth, inequality and social protection, Roman Arjona, Maxime
Ladaique, Mark Pearson OECD, January 26-27th , 2001 Chateau Laurier
Hotel, Ottawa, Ontario http://www.csls.ca/jan01/pearson.pdf
3. Business must not be as usual, and the "Dalhousie School" of
Economics, by Mario deSantis, February 26, 2001 http://www.ftlcomm.com/ensign/desantisArticles/2001_300/desantis334/dalhousie.html
4. Canada can outdo U.S. economy, Martin says, Alan Toulin,
National Post, February 28, 2001 http://www.nationalpost.com/home/story.html?f=/stories/20010228/487081.html
5. The real challenge of David Dodge, Brian K. MacLean, Financial
Post/National Post, December 26, 2000 http://www.geocities.com/brian79
6. Address by A. Charles Baillie, Chairman & Chief Executive
Officer TD Bank Financial Group to The Canadian Club, Toronto,
February 26, 2001 http://www.tdbank.ca/tdtoday/speeches/26feb01.html
7. Profits up at CIBC, bank raises dividend, CBC Canada, March 1,
2001 http://cbc.ca/cgi-bin/templates/view.cgi?/news/2001/03/01/cibcearnings_010301 |