Finally there is convergence of opinion about health care and I am
pleased to recognize that The StarPhoenix along with many
researchers across Canada come aboard with our ancient and
reiterating opinion that our health care system is mismanaged. In
the "Health system bows to market"(1) we find the nightmare we are
presently undergoing: the departure of neurosurgeons, of
anesthesiologists, of pediatricians and other medical specialists.
And to summarize our Saskatchewan's scenario, the authors of this
article state that while commissioner Ken Fyke is busy asking
ordinary residents on how to reform the system, the system is
reforming itself in response to economic market forces. Also, these
authors state that we need new leaders who can prescribe strong
medicine rather than "push more placebos in the form of poorly
designed health districts or meaningless studies."
Commissioner Ken Fyke has not understood yet that the health care
problems are of a leadership and structural nature and has
creatively stated "We can pay for the service by raising taxes
through the public sector, we can bring additional revenue in
through premiums, or... user fees(2) ." In the meantime the
commissioner will be sending 400,000 surveys to Saskatchewan homes,
as well as holding TV forums, maintaining a web site, and setting up
a 1-800 number(3). Just to have an indication of one direct cost of
this study we can multiply the 400,000 surveys by the nominal unit
cost of $1 per survey and we have a cost of $400,000. And I am not
sure if these $400,000 are part of Ken Fyke's $2 million budget.
Dr. John Horne, a Winnipeg health economist and advisor to the
Canadian Institute for Health Information, has said "We know we have
too few nurses coast to coast. We have too few physicians,
particularly specialty physicians. We have too few pharmacists, too
few lab technologists, too few ultrasound techs and respiratory
techs. There's an emerging shortage of health care workers(4)." In
the last three years health care spending has increased by 22% yet
our surgical waiting times have increased, and they are still
increasing in Saskatchewan(5).
According to the Canadian Institute for Health Information most
of the new spending has been used on capital projects. Dr. Brent
Burbridge, head of medical imaging for the College of Medicine at
the University of Saskatchewan, said there is a "gross deficit" of
capital equipment funding in many provinces. "Things are desperate.
I don't believe we are providing state of the art care here, I can
tell you that. And that's because we don't have the most current
equipment(6)."
In the last years we have experienced the downsizing of our
health facilities, and as a consequence a sizeable portion of the
above mentioned 22% increase in health care spending has been
allocated for the implementation of obsolete Information Technology
systems. And in Saskatchewan this system is called the Saskatchewan
Health Information System (SHIN), a system which has pumped
approximately $40 million into the sewage(7), not to speak about the
lateral and consequential misuse of health resources.
The saga of health care mismanagement is continuing and we will
be ready to tell you additional stories.
References/Endnotes
1. Health system bows to market, OPINIONS, October 13, 2000, The
StarPhoenix, Saskatoon, Saskatchewan
2. First report outlines health care challenges, CBC
Saskatchewan, http://sask.cbc.ca Web Posted | Oct 6 2000 9:35 PM EDT
3. First report outlines health care challenges, CBC
Saskatchewan, http://sask.cbc.ca Web Posted | Oct 6 2000 9:35 PM EDT
4. $64-billion insufficient to stop bleeding, Brad Evenson,
National Post, October 12, 2000
5. Surgical waiting game continues: Former task force members
lament slow progress in shortening province's waiting lists, by
Murray Mandryk, The StarPhoenix, October 14, 2000, Saskatoon,
Saskatchewan
6. X-Ray Labs dangerously outdated. Radiologists sound alarm:
Equipment so archaic that even Cambodian refugee camp doesn't want
it, Tom Arnold, National Post, October 12, 2000
7. Saskatchewan Health Care: Confirmation Of The Most Mismanaged
System In Canada, by Mario deSantis, October 12, 2000 |